A quick thought on feedback…
It’s impossible to master any art without feedback. Actively seeking out, and being open to, feedback is essential to improving. Regardless of what skill you’re trying to improve.
But, as my friend and colleague Jeff texted to me yesterday, “People can be so stupid and evil.”
He was responding to a photo I sent him of a feedback card I got. It read only, “Why would you write this.” No question mark. “Why would you write this” period.
Actually, the feedback card asked for input at the top. It asked, “When did you catch your mind wandering away?” Next to that question the respondent wrote in, “Immediately.” Below that they wrote, “Why would you write this.”
I’ve rarely encountered this level of hostility from respondents. Most people, even if they don’t like a piece, and you’ve asked them to help you, will try to help you with some semblance of nicety. Of course, it’s possible this person thought they were helping me by confronting me with displeasure.
And, in a way, they have helped.
They’ve helped me realize — for the umpteenth time! — that writing is always a vulnerable act. You don’t get to put your writing in front of people in emotional safety. First there’s the risk of boring other people. But then there’s the risk of incurring other people’s wrath. “Wrath” can mean a lot of things, obviously. It can mean irritation. It can mean moral condemnation. It can mean literal, red-faced, shouting rage.
And you run this risk even if your material is perfectly conventional. Meaning, think about the aesthetic outrage directed at the writers of Star Wars movies and TV shows. It’s hard to get more conventional, more people-pleasing, more commercial, and more cozily familiar than Star Wars. And yet the producers and writers and actors of Star Wars projects have suspended their social media accounts because of bullying. (And there’s effectively no risk that one failed Star Wars project will end the franchise. There’s probably going to be plenty of more Stars Wars content through 2100.)
Anyway… Just a reminder to myself, I suppose. Putting your writing out there will always potentially expose you to meanness.
